In my experience, it’s the fasting window that really matters. This may be unpopular, but my attitude is that as long as I had 16 hours I’m good. Sometimes it’s 20, sometimes it’s much longer. And every once in a while, I feel like it’s not the end of the world to blow off fasting for various reasons. It’s been very effective for me.
There’s new research to suggest that the time of the window may make a difference. Thomas Delauer just did a video recapping that study. It’s new so FWiW but the research suggests that making your eating windows in the early morning from 6a-3p may be more beneficial than eating from 1p-8p.