| | Water Fasting

How can milk of different brands have such varying amounts of vitamins and minerals?

I use this website to look up nutritional data on common food products. This product is soy milk 1 cup and it shows 60mg calcium or 6% dv. Meanwhile, Silk Soy Milk contains 450mg calcium or 30% dv.

Another example, with whole milk. Brand A has 282 mg of calcium or 20% dv, while this Brand B has 30% dv for calcium. How do seemingly similar problems vary so much in their contents?

Is there a good website for checking average values for nutritional values in common food products?

Thank you for answering any of my question.

Stop Fasting Alone.

Get a private coach and accountability partner for daily check-in's and to help you reach your fasting goals. Any kind of fasting protocol is supported.

Request more information and pricing.

Answer

Soy milk does not naturally contain a lot of calcium; it is added.

Since you are looking at a website rather than physical products, I would guess that one whole milk has the new nutrition facts panel and one the older one. The amount of calcium for %DV went up from 1000mg to 1300 mg. https://www.fda.gov/media/135301/download

Answer

Are they different types of milk? If they’re not dairy, they are likely to have different numbers because of the processing. Some use more water, some less. If it’s dairy, the filtration process and what the cows eat can effect the quality of the milk

Answer

In terms of real milk. Yes. It varies pretty fairly based on the animals feed and management. Better conditions and nourishment = better nutrient content. This also goes for the least processed milk since most of it is overly treated.

As for fake milks, they are not very nutrient dense. So to compensate for this (like in any highly processed food) they fortify it with vitamins and minerals (although usually it’s poorly bioavailable forms anyway).

My suggestion? Stop obsessing over specific nutrient differences. Buy high quality food, buy least processed and drink/eat away.

Related Fasting Blogs