| | Water Fasting

Is it true that drinking ANY kind of fluid, even it has no calories can interfere with autophagy?

M24, 92kg here

So I practice OMAD as I fast for between 18 to 23 hours everyday depending on circumstances. My main goal is fat burn, ketosis as well as autophagy. I track my progress with the Fastic app as I weightlift and do some brisk walking too.

So, I’m rather self-conscious about my health especially eyesight. This may sound odd but I care a lot about my eyesight more than anything and I figured autophagy would be a way to keep my eye cells such as retina cells in good condition (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27983732/).

I’m not diagnosed with AMD or anything but I do what I can to keep my eye health in good shape thus I’m worried that drinking ANYTHING, even if it has no calories such as water or black coffee can break autophagy. How true is this? Thank you in advance.

Stop Fasting Alone.

Get a private coach and accountability partner for daily check-in's and to help you reach your fasting goals. Any kind of fasting protocol is supported.

Request more information and pricing.

Answer

I have a hard time believing that drinking water or black coffee will set you back in any meaningful way. Maybe it disrupts autophagy for a short time, but what are we talking about, 15 minutes?

I mean, you have to drink something, so water intake is the most natural thing in the world, right?

I would keep your water intake up at a couple of litres per day or whatever is recommended for your weight index and not worry about it.

Answer

My 2 cents.

Due to a health issue and recent non-response to a treatment that should have worked, I have made it a mission to ascertain as much as possible to give my body an edge in achieving optimal health.

I am currently a huge fan of various fasting protocols and I am now doing 19/5 or 20/4 IF.

Based on my research, water with the big 3 electrolytes is a must.

Black coffee and tea are fine - as long as there are ZERO sugar, almond milk, etc. If it has a calorie - avoid it.

And forget about artificial sweeteners. Even though they have no calories they are sweet to the taste. This can elicit cephalic insulin response. Your body, as a response to the sweet taste, releases insulin which probably does inhibit autophagy.

Answer

As a notoriously wet part of the human body I’d be surprised if it was good for your eyes to be dehydrated in any way.

​

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7551870/ This paper describes several benefits of intermittent fasting on eye health markers in mouse models, and if you follow through each of those references in the eye section you can see that the mice are always given 24/7 unrestricted access to water i.e. this is about water fasting not dry fasting.

​

Stay hydrated.

Related Fasting Blogs